Why You Shouldn’t Chase Implied Vol After a Realized Vol Spike

Some new traders watch realized volatility (RV) and expect implied volatility (IV) to follow. But does that work?

It sounds logical — If the stock has gotten more volatile, shouldn’t option prices rise to reflect that?

Well… not so fast.

In fact, one of the easiest ways to lose money trading options is to assume implied volatility must catch up to realized volatility after a big move.

📊 Realized Vol Is the Past. Implied Vol Is the Future.

Realized volatility is a historical metric. It tells you how much a stock has been moving—usually measured over the past 10 to 30 days.

Implied volatility, on the other hand, is forward-looking. It reflects what the market thinks could happen over the life of an option.

When realized vol spikes as earnings drop or headlines hit the tape—that’s backward-looking data. The event has happened. And ironically, that’s often the moment when the market expects things to settle down, not stay chaotic.

So while RV might spike to 50%, IV might only move up modestly—or even fall—as the market prices in mean reversion.

🔁 Vol Spikes Are Usually Short-Lived

Historically, volatility spikes don’t last long. Panic sellers dump shares, market makers hedge aggressively, and volume explodes… then it dies down just as fast.

Markets are efficient at pricing shocks, but not every shock leads to a regime change.

So if you're buying options just because “realized vol is higher than implied,” you’re betting that the recent chaos will continue—and that the market hasn’t already priced that in.

That’s a tough edge to sustain.

🪫 The Vega Trap

Here’s the trap: options might look “cheap” relative to realized vol, but if the shock fades quickly (as it usually does), your options lose value as IV compresses. This is called vega decay—and it can hit hard even when you’re “directionally right.”

---

💡 The Smarter Move: Fade the Spike

When realized vol spikes but implied vol doesn’t keep pace, it’s often a volatility selling opportunity, not a buying one.

✅ Trade Idea: Short-Term Call or Put Spreads

If you're expecting volatility to mean revert after a sharp move, consider trades like:

• Bear call spreads (if the underlying just spiked higher and IV is rich)

• Bull put spreads (if the underlying dropped and you expect stabilization)

• Iron condors (if you think a period of consolidation is coming)

These structures benefit from IV compression and time decay, while limiting your risk.

Here’s a general setup: